Triveni Cement Ltd. (TCL) is an Indian company, having its head office at Chennai. For the P.Y. 2024-25, it furnished the following information of…
CA Final · Direct Tax Laws and International Taxation · RTP · May 2025
Triveni Cement Ltd. (TCL) is an Indian company, having its head office at Chennai. For the P.Y. 2024-25, it furnished the following information of certain entities and the transactions undertaken with these companies: Drift Inc. is a wholly owned foreign subsidiary in Japan of TCL. It is currently paying royalty of USD 3 million per annum to TCL for supply of know-how. For similar supply of know how to Elite LLC., a wholly owned Government Company in Japan, TCL receives annual royalty of USD 4 million. (1 USD = 82). TCL has borrowed a sum of equivalent of 220 crores from Swift Inc., Dubai on 1.4.2024. On this date, the assets position of TCL was as under: Type of assets Market value Book value Tangible fixed assets 350 270 Intangible assets 50 25 Other assets 40 35 Swift Inc., has charged interest at 8% and TCL has paid interest of 17.6 crores for the year ended 31.3.2025. Though the normal lending rate of Swift Inc. was 7% per annum to other parties, in view of the urgent requirement of funds and pressing financial commitments, TCL decided to borrow this amount then. TCL supplies goods to True Words Ltd. (TWL), in Singapore. The paid-up capital of TWL in foreign currency equivalent is 92 crores. TCL holds shares to the tune of 22 crores in TWL. The voting power in the company is directly proportional to the number of shares held. You are required to examine the various transactions entered into by TCL and determine the applicability of transfer pricing provisions for each transaction. Ignore provisions of section 94B, if applicable, in this case.
Suggested Answer and Working Notes:
Any income arising from an international transaction, between two or more "associated enterprises", shall be computed having regard to arm's length price as per the provisions of Chapter X of the Act. Section 92A defines an "associated enterprise" and sub-section (2) of this section speaks of the situations when the two enterprises shall be deemed to be associated enterprises. Transaction with Drift Inc. Drift Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of TCL and is a non-resident company. Hence, it is an associated enterprise. Royalty falls within the meaning of international transaction, since it is payment for supply of know-how, being an intangible property. Drift Inc. is currently paying a royalty of USD 3 million per annum to TCL for supply of know-how. For similar supply of know how to Elite LLC., a wholly owned Government Company in Japan, TCL receives annual royalty of USD 4 million. Under CUP Method, ALP has to be taken as USD 4 million. Understatement of royalty is 1 million USD, i.e., 1 M USD x 82 = 820 lakhs. Transaction with Swift Inc. As per section 92A (2) , if one enterprise advances loan to the other enterprise of an amount of 51% or more of the book value of the total assets of such other enterprise, the two enterprises would be deemed to be associated enterprises. As on the date of borrowing, the amount advanced is 220crores out of 330crores, which comes to 66.67%. Hence, Swift Inc., is deemed to be an associated enterprise of TCL. Interest payments are also covered by the term "international transaction". Swift Inc., has charged interest at 8% and TCL has paid interest of 17.6 crores for the year ended 31.3.2025. Interest rate charged to other parties is 7%. This has to be taken as the ALP rate. In the light of this, the interest payment should have been 17.6 x 7/8 i.e.,15.4 crores. There has been an excess payment of 2.2 crores above the ALP. Transaction with TWL In TWL, TCL holds 22/92 i.e., 23.91% of the voting power. Since TCL holds less than 26% of the voting power, TWL is not an associated enterprise. Hence, the transfer pricing provisions would not be applicable on sales made by TCL to TWL.
Topics: Transfer Pricing
Related Questions in this Topic
- PG Ltd., an Indian Company, has borrowed ₹ 90 crores on 01-04-2025 from M/s. Capital Inc, a company incorporated in Lond...
- (I) Xylo Ltd., operating in India, is the dealer for the goods manufactured by Yoyo Ltd. of Japan. Yoyo Ltd. owns 55% sh...
- Euphoric Ltd. having its registered office in Chennai is engaged in multiple businesses. It buys mobile phones from its ...
- M/s Alpha Investments Ltd., an investment company, held 2,00,000 shares of Beta Alloys Ltd. as stock-in-trade. Pursuant ...
- Trex Ltd., an Indian Company, on 01-04-2024 has borrowed 90 crores from M/s Refine Inc, a Company incorporated in Countr...