Specify with reason, whether the following acts can be considered as: (A) Tax planning; or (B) Tax management; or (C) Tax evasion. 1. Mr. D has FDR…
CA Final · Direct Tax Laws and International Taxation · PYQS · May 2024
Specify with reason, whether the following acts can be considered as: (A) Tax planning; or (B) Tax management; or (C) Tax evasion. 1. Mr. D has FDR with SBI in his name amounting to 50 lakhs. He gifted this sum of 50 lakhs to his son, on 10.04.2023, the date on which he attained 18 years of age. The purpose is to shift interest income from his hands to his son, so that there may be Zero tax implication, since his son has no other income and the total interest would be lower than taxable limits for P.Y. 2023-24. 2. Mr. Ram's Annual income is 49.50 lakhs for A.Y. 2024-25 excluding commission receivable from ABC Limited. During March 2024, he earned a commission of 6 lakhs from ABC Limited. He asked ABC Limited to transfer the commission in his wife's account, who is a housewife. He also asked them to deduct TDS in her wife's name. He did it so that his total income may not cross 50 lakhs and he can save surcharge on taxes applicable on total income exceeding 50 lakhs. His wife has no other income.
Suggested Answer and Working Notes:
1. Tax Planning – Gifting of fixed deposits of 50lakhs by Mr. D to his son who attained the age of 18 years for the purpose of shifting interest income from his hands to his son so that there may be zero tax implication, is a permitted tax planning measure under the provisions of income-tax law. Note - It has been assumed that such transfer is irrevocable and Mr. D does not derive any direct or indirect benefit from such income. In case transfer of fixed deposit is revocable then the interest income on fixed deposits would be included in the hands of Mr. D and hence the same would not be considered as Tax Planning. 2. Tax Evasion - Mr. Ram's annual income is 49.50 lakhs for the Α.Υ. 2024-25. He also earned commission of 6lakhs from ABC Limited. Accordingly, his total income would be - 55.50 lakhs which exceeds 50lakhs and hence surcharge is applicable on tax on total income. However, for the purpose of saving tax, he instructed ABC Ltd. to transfer the commission in his wife's account. This is the case of application of income and not of diversion of income by overriding title, since such transfer of commission is not under any obligation but to evade tax. This is tax evasion.
Topics: Tax Audit and Ethical Compliance
Related Questions in this Topic
- Correct & Co, a firm engaged in retail business, employed 30 new employees on 1.4.2025 on a monthly salary of ₹ 24,500 t...
- Mr. Rinku, an individual whose total sales in the business of food grains for the year ending 31.3.2026 was ₹ 305 lakhs,...
- An enquiry under Section 133(6) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 was initiated by the Income-tax Department on 18th Nov. 2025...
- Anahita Ltd., an Indian company engaged in producing electrical equipment, during the financial year 2025-26, paid inter...
- What is meant by Digital economy? What are the taxation issues in E-Commerce? List out the OECD recommendations under Ac...